Credit cards vs Afterpay: the smarter way to spend the same money

Millions of Australians use Afterpay or another Buy Now Pay Later (BNPL) service at least once every 6 months. Few stop to notice that while BNPL works well for spreading the cost of a retail purchase, it does nothing for you on groceries, bills, subscriptions, or that flight you just booked.

A rewards card, used by someone with sound financial habits and the same discipline to pay on time, will accumulate more value with each purchase and may also benefit from interest-free days.

Both options have their place, and this comparison is not about telling you what to do. It is about making sure you have the full picture. If you consistently pay on time and you have never really thought about what your everyday spending could be earning you, that is exactly what we are here to unpack.

Here’s how the two stack up side by side.

Afterpay vs credit cards: at a glance

Feature	Afterpay	Credit card
Costs and fees
Annual fee	None	$0 to $700+ depending on card tier
Interest charges	None	None, if paid in full monthly. Rates typically 20% to 22% p.a. if the balance is carried
Late fees	Up to $68 or 25% of the order value, whichever is lower. The average late payment fee is believed to be >$120.	Typically $10 to $30 per missed payment, varies by issuer
Currency conversion	Primarily AUD domestic transactions only	Accepted in foreign currencies; some cards charge 2% to 3% conversion fee
Rewards and benefits
Earn points on spend	No	Yes, on almost every dollar spent
Sign-up bonus points	No	Yes, often substantial on eligible cards
Airport lounge access	No	Yes, on premium cards
Overseas travel insurance	No	Yes, on eligible cards when flights are booked with the card
Purchase protection	No	Yes, on many cards
Consumer protections
Chargeback and dispute rights	Limited. Disputes handled through Afterpay and merchant only	Strong chargeback rights via Visa and Mastercard networks
Minimum spend for benefits	None	Some benefits, such as travel insurance, require minimum spend or booking conditions
Eligibility and access
Credit check required	Soft check only, no formal assessment	Formal credit assessment required
Repayment structure	4 fortnightly instalments, fixed schedule	Full monthly statement cycle with nominated due date; typically 44 to 55 interest-free days
Spend limits	Lower initially, increases with on-time payment history	Higher initial limits, subject to credit assessment
Credit file impact	Minimal	Builds positively with responsible use. Adverse events can affect future credit applications.
Usability
Accepted merchants	Participating retailers only, primarily online and e-commerce	Accepted virtually everywhere globally, in-store and online
Apple Pay and Google Pay	Yes	Yes

Is Afterpay really free? What are the fees?

Afterpay positions itself as free when you pay on time, and technically, that is accurate. There are no annual fees and no interest. But “no fees” is not the same as “no cost,” and there are two things worth understanding before accepting it outright.

Firstly, miss a payment on a $120 Afterpay order, and you are charged $10 for the missed payment, plus a further $7 if it remains unpaid after 7 days, bringing your total to $137 for a $120 purchase. With a credit card, missing a payment does not trigger a flat fee on most Australian cards.

Instead, you lose your interest-free period and interest begins accruing on your balance. On $120 left unpaid for 30 days at 20% per year, that’s around $2. The scenarios are not identical, but the point is clear: Afterpay’s late cost on smaller purchases can be proportionally higher than most people expect.

Secondly, the fees merchants pay for BNPL transactions are significantly higher than those on credit cards. Over time, it could well be that merchant resistance to these fees will see an increase in costs to BNPL users or an overall increase in prices.

Beyond the fees, every time you use Afterpay instead of a rewards card, you forgo points on that purchase. Over a year of everyday spending, that adds up to something real, even if it never appears on a statement. Afterpay is free until it is not. What it costs you over time is simply harder to see.

Do credit card annual fees cancel out the benefits? 

For most people who spend regularly and pay their balance in full, no, because the annual fee is typically offset by the benefits it provides. Premium cards often include complimentary travel insurance worth $150 to $300 per trip, lounge access passes valued at $50 to $80 each, and points earning rates that translate into real travel value for frequent spenders.

It is a fair question to ask, and the answer depends on how you use the card. Entry-level cards carry no annual fee at all. On premium cards, the fee is better thought of as a subscription to a set of benefits, one that pays for itself if you travel even once or twice a year.

Are there any other credit card fees to be aware of?

In the interest of a complete picture, credit cards can carry a small number of additional fees depending on how they are used:

• Foreign transaction fees: typically 2% to 3% on purchases made in foreign currencies. Several travel-focused cards waive these entirely.
• Cash advance fees: apply when a credit card is used to withdraw cash, attracting an immediate charge and interest from day one, with no interest-free period.
• Additional cardholder fees: some cards charge between $50 and $100 per year for adding a secondary cardholder.

These are legitimate costs and worth understanding before choosing a card. That said, they are also entirely avoidable. Someone moving from Afterpay to a rewards credit card is unlikely to encounter any of them in the normal course of spending.

Foreign transaction fees apply only when spending in foreign currency. Cash advances are a specific and deliberate action, not a default feature of card use. Additional cardholder fees only apply if you choose to add one. For someone who uses a credit card for everyday purchases and travel bookings and pays the balance in full each month, none of these fees is likely to be relevant.

How much does a missed payment actually cost? 

Afterpay caps its late fees, which it presents as a consumer protection. Take a common scenario: booking a domestic flight. While Jetstar does, other major Australian airlines, including Qantas and Virgin Australia, do not offer Afterpay at checkout. That alone is worth pausing on.

1. With a credit card

So you book the $800 flight with a rewards credit card instead. Within your 55-day interest-free period, and assuming your previous balance was cleared, no interest applies. Pay it off before the due date, and the flight costs you $800. You have also earned points on the booking and, depending on your card, activated complimentary travel insurance for the trip.

Now, imagine you miss the payment due date. At a typical interest rate of around 20% p.a., leaving $800 unpaid for 30 days costs you approximately $13 in interest. That is the downside of a poorly handled credit card.

2. With Afterpay

Here is where it gets interesting. Afterpay does not quote late fees as an interest rate, but the numbers tell a different story. Miss a payment on an $800 Afterpay order, and you are charged $10. Miss the seven-day window after that, and another $7 applies. That is $17 per instalment, equivalent to an annualised rate that would make most credit cards look competitive. The framing is different. The cost is not.

There is one meaningful distinction: if you miss a payment with Afterpay, your account is paused, and you cannot make new purchases until you are back on track. A credit card does not impose that kind of circuit breaker, which for some people is a genuine feature of the BNPL model. But for someone who manages their finances carefully, that guardrail is not the point. The point is what you are earning, or not, while you spend.

What happens if something goes wrong with a purchase?

When a purchase goes wrong, the difference between Afterpay and a credit card becomes most tangible: with a credit card, you have the right to lodge a chargeback. Your card issuer can reverse the transaction on your behalf via the Visa or Mastercard network, placing the burden of proof on the merchant. This is a well-established mechanism for resolving disputes in favour of cardholders.

With Afterpay, your dispute process runs through Afterpay and the merchant directly. If the merchant is uncooperative, your options are more limited. Critically, your fortnightly instalments continue regardless of whether your dispute has been resolved. If the dispute is upheld, a refund will follow, but in the interim, you are still paying for something you may be returning. 

Under the Australian Consumer Law, you retain your rights regardless of how you paid, but the practical mechanism for enforcing them is considerably stronger with a credit card.

Could Afterpay or a credit card affect your ability to borrow?

Both Afterpay and credit cards can affect your ability to get a home loan, and most people do not find out until they are already applying. Lenders look at your BNPL instalments and your credit card limit as financial commitments, even if you always pay on time and rarely carry a balance. What catches people off guard is that your credit card is assessed on your total limit, not what you actually owe. A card you barely use can still reduce what a lender will offer you.

Does Afterpay or a credit card do more with your data?

This is a question most people never think to ask, but it is worth understanding. Afterpay’s privacy policy states that it may share customer data with third-party partners, including Meta (Facebook), for targeted advertising purposes, using purchase behaviour and browsing data to serve personalised ads. This is not unique to Afterpay (many BNPL platforms operate this way), but it is worth knowing.

Credit card issuers in Australia are authorised deposit-taking institutions regulated by APRA and are subject to the Australian Privacy Act 1988 under stricter obligations than non-bank lenders and BNPL providers. While they do collect and use customer data, they operate under a more tightly regulated framework for data sharing and consumer consent.

Are all credit card points created equal?

Not quite. One of the advantages of a rewards credit card that often goes unnoticed is flexibility. Points earned through a credit card rewards program can typically be transferred to multiple frequent flyer and hotel programs, including Qantas Frequent Flyer, Velocity, and various international airline partners, depending on the card. That means the value of your points is not tied to a single program or redemption type. You can choose to use them for flights, upgrades, hotel stays, or even shopping rewards through programs like Qantas Shopping. Afterpay offers no equivalent, and the spending you do through it accumulates nothing that can be redirected, transferred, or used toward a future goal.

Summing up: Afterpay vs credit cards

Credit cards only make sense if you pay your balance in full each month. If you carry a balance, interest charges will quickly outweigh any rewards you earn. If you find it difficult to pay bills on time, Afterpay’s fixed schedule may suit your situation better. But for those who can commit to paying monthly, the value of a rewards credit card becomes considerably clearer.

For anyone who pays their balance in full each month, a rewards credit card will outperform Afterpay across the full scope of their spending. Afterpay is free when used perfectly and genuinely useful for spreading retail costs. But it earns you nothing on that spending, offers no travel cover, and gives you less protection if a purchase goes wrong. You are already spending the money.

A rewards credit card can turn that spending into flights, lounge access, and travel cover. Afterpay doesn’t. Even if you pay your Afterpay instalments using a credit card, most card issuers do not award points on BNPL repayments. If you are very disciplined and want to use Afterpay with a credit card, keep in mind that if you do this, missing a payment could trigger consequences on both platforms.

At Point Hacks, we exist to help Australians travel better for less. That mission starts long before the airport. It starts at the checkout, the grocery run, the subscription renewal. Every dollar spent on a rewards credit card is a dollar that could eventually take you somewhere.

Frequently asked questions

Community Comments

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Comment *

Name *

Email *

Website

Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.

Δ